Tag-Edited CC Won't Show Up

Heyo! So I have a piece of CC I want to change to a tattoo or face detail (either way, something that won't come off with outfit changes) instead of what it is currently, which is facepaint. I've done it before with Sims Studio, and now that I've tried to go and do it after a long time, I've somehow made it now show up in game at all! I'm not sure what I did, as I've tried to enable it only for aliens, but it doesnt show up for them. However, it does show up for humans. Is there something I'm doing wrong? I have certainly done it with the same piece of CC before, but don't have the old modified version on my PC anymore after I've factory reset it.

Does anyone know what I'm doing wrong? Or perhaps the right steps to do what I want to do?

It is the Out Of This World facepaint from this CC pack:

plumbobteasociety.tumblr.com/post/150541385473/stellar-stuff-for-sims-4-a-collaboration-between