Seperated object doesn't look how it's supposed to

Hi. I seperated the clutter from te bookcase that came with the pastel pop kit, using the stack of books as a base mesh. The other items look fine, but the tray with the vase is giving me issues.


On the left you can see what it is supposed to look like; on the right what it actually looks like. 



I checked the mesh & the UV looks ok in blender.




What am I missing? 

Here's the mesh: simfileshare.net/download/3550963/



Thanks in advance for the help.